When I tell people that the Maldives may have a continental shelf, I do get a very appropriate response. It usually is a friendly, “you must be pulling my leg?”, or the less friendly, “you are really going to put your foot in it,” or the more sarcastic, “my foot!”
Well, all these responses have hit the nail on the head: it is all about the “foot” and finding the “foot” at the right depth and distance.
But, before I get to that, let me set the context for the Maldives quest for the extended continental shelf.
Scramble for the SeabedOver the last year or so, there has been a frenzy of claims to portions of the seabed from nearly pole to pole. Nation-states are in a mad scramble (especially by those who are fleet of foot) to claim large tracts of the underwater world for rights to exploit the abundant mineral wealth on the seabed – a land-grab not seen since the 19th century scramble for Africa. Why? The time-limit set to advance such claims by the Law of the Sea Convention for countries who had ratified the treaty before 1999 was 13 May 2009.
On 7 August 2009, the Maldives informed the UN Commission on the Limits of the Continental Shelf that it cannot consent to the claim lodged by Sri Lanka on the extent of the latter’s continental shelf beyond 200 nautical miles to the southwest. The reason is that the Maldives itself may have a claim which overlaps the extended EEZ of Sri Lanka.
Sri Lanka had submitted their claim to an extended continental shelf on 8 May 2009. And it comes very close to our EEZ.
Sri Lanka's ClaimI requested President Nasheed to immediately set up a high-level committee to review the Sri Lankan claim, which he did the same day. The Maldives had upto 3 months to comment on Sri Lanka’s submission, and hence the notification made on 7 August.
Now, the Maldives must prepare its own claim to an extended continental shelf. It would be vital that we make our own claim, subject to compliance with the legal definition of a continental shelf under the Law of the Sea Convention.
The Maldives ratified the Convention in September 2000. So we have until September 2010 to make that claim, or at the least, submit preliminary information and an intended date for the submission of the full claim.
For years, the government of Maldives had got off on the wrong foot by relying on a study done by an expert in the early 1990s. The study dismissed the idea that the Maldives may have a continental margin that extended beyond 200 nautical miles into the sea. After all, the Maldives are on a ridge and the atolls have a very steep slope just a few metres into the sea. So what continental shelf?
But in June 2007, the Attorney-General, Dr Hassan Saeed, began to review this position and fresh inquiries were made through the UN.
It also became apparent that trouble could brew up in the Indian Ocean, with some of the islands in the region preparing their claims, and that some of the claims could affect the Maldives, especially given that there was no demarcation of maritime boundary in the south.
Even after Hassan and I quit the government in August 2007, we alerted the concerned civil servants to follow up on the matter.
In the public domain, too, the issued raised its head every now and then, particularly following remarks made about the matter in political rallies by Hassan. But, in the media coverage, and in the government’s response, there was considerable confusion about what was exactly the issue – because there were several unresolved issues about our maritime boundary.
Some of the confusion persists, as do the unresolved issues.
But, for the most part, the confusion relates to a technicality, a vital technicality. It is the variance between the normal definition of a continental shelf, which is the submerged piece of land before the steep slope, and the legal definition established by the Law of the Sea Convention.
Normal sense of a continental shelfThe definition in the Law of Sea Convention provides for an extended continental shelf beyond the continental slope into the area called the continental rise which is at the foot of the continental slope. Given a certain thickness of the sedimentation and depth, a portion of the continental rise can also be claimed as extended continental shelf, up to a total maximum of 360 nautical miles from the shore. It is all in Article76 of the Law of the Sea Convention. And establishing the foot of the slope is critical.
As defined by the Law of the Sea ConventionThe area beyond the 200 nautical mile EEZ will be international waters, but the State which claims the extended continental shelf will have the sole right to the mineral wealth on the seabed.
There is a good chance that the Maldives will be able to substantiate a claim to an extended continental shelf, especially if the depth of the seas does not reach 2.5 km before a distance of 100 nautical miles from the shore or, as the jargon goes, the baseline.
Even if the technical data (bathymetric and geodetic) were to show that the Maldives does not qualify for an extended shelf, it would be incumbent upon the government to determine the situation on facts rather than assumptions.
The downside is the cost of the whole enterprise. Sri Lanka’s study is reported to have cost over 6 million dollars!
But fortunately, there are ways to find donors to foot the bill. Funds are available for this purpose through the UN and a case can be made to obtain such funds.
Such funds become available if the Maldives can demonstrate by a “desktop” study by using generally available scientific data that there is a prima facie case for an extended shelf claim. And, for that process, there are many friendly countries and organisations willing to help.
Indeed, that work has already begun.
At the end of the day, the mineral wealth on the seabed would prove to be too valuable to be ignored, and a few million dollars spent to secure national rights over them will be a worthwhile investment for our future generations.
The challenge really is to identify the foot of the slope before a depth of 2.5 km is reached, and beyond a distance of 100 nautical miles from the base shoreline.